I have a question?

While I agree, I don't see an actual question, i won't bash you for it. The underlying question here is obvious to me that "Did I vote the right way?". Yes, you did! Even though it is a mock trial my friend, the Prosecution must prove beyongd ANY reasonable doubt that the defendant is guilty. Having been on a city champion mock trial team, it sounds to me like they needed to prepare better, but I have seen real cases won by the defense when the attorney was a total moron. Better luck next time!